If you're buying an older Keys home and planning a big renovation, the 50% rule may be the most important rule you've never heard of. It decides whether you can remodel the house as it stands, or whether the whole house has to be brought up to current code first.
Under FEMA's National Flood Insurance Program and the Florida Building Code, when the cost of improving or repairing a building in a flood zone equals or exceeds 50% of the building's market value, the work is a "substantial improvement" (or "substantial damage" after a storm). The whole building must then be brought up to current code. Only the building counts, not the land.
The whole building has to meet today's code, not just the part you're working on. That includes the flood rules: the lowest floor must be at least one foot above the base flood elevation for its flood zone, and the area underneath can only be used for parking, storage and access to the building, with no living space. For many older ground-level homes, that means raising the house or tearing it down and rebuilding.
Homes that don't meet current code. That's mostly homes built below flood before 1975, which are legal nonconforming (grandfathered), and homes built at flood but not a foot above it. A home's grandfathered status ends once it's renovated past the 50% mark. See our flood zones page for more on legal and illegal below-flood living space.
It's the value of the building only, not the land and not the price you paid. That surprises a lot of buyers. On a waterfront property, much of the price can be the lot itself, so the 50% limit can be far lower than half of what you paid for the home.
Keys building departments generally start with the Monroe County Property Appraiser's building value and add an adjustment; Key West, for example, adds 15%. If you think that number is too low, you can usually submit an independent appraisal of the building instead.
In some places, yes. The 50% isn't always counted one permit at a time: a building department can add together all the work done on a house over a set period. Key West, for example, adds up all the work done within one year.
Say a Key West home's adjusted market value is $460,000, so the limit is $230,000. A $120,000 kitchen in March is fine on its own, and so is $130,000 of baths and windows in September. But together that's $250,000 in one year, so the whole house would have to be brought up to current code. Splitting one big job into several smaller permits doesn't get around it either.
Each Keys city and the county sets its own period, and several have changed recently, so we check with that building department before you buy.
Nearly everything on the permit: new kitchens and baths, windows and doors, electrical and plumbing, additions and structural work, including both materials and labor. Routine maintenance isn't meant to be discouraged, but if the work needs a permit, the building official looks at the full cost of the project.
The same rule applies to storm damage. If repairing a home would cost 50% or more of its market value before the storm, it's substantially damaged and must be brought up to current code when it's rebuilt.
Before you buy an older home you plan to renovate, we look at the elevation certificate, the year it was built and the property appraiser's building value, so you know roughly how much work you can do before the 50% rule kicks in. For example, in Key West a home with a building value of $400,000 would have an adjusted market value of $460,000, leaving about $230,000 of work in a year before the whole house must be brought up to current code, no matter what the home and land sold for. Sometimes the numbers show that raising or rebuilding is the better plan from the start.
Have a specific property in mind? Contact us and we'll help you run the numbers. You can also read about insurance in the Keys or return to the Florida Keys Buyer's Guide.
All information on this page about the 50% rule is our personal opinion and should not be relied on. Rules and calculation methods vary by jurisdiction; please contact the building department for the property for an official determination. FEMA's substantial damage and improvement guide has more detail.
Active listings, pending and sold properties, and market data for the area you care about.
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll set up a custom search. New listings that match arrive in your inbox daily, weekly or monthly.
Freshest data available
Active listings only
Customizable search options
New listing alerts
Instant home value assessments
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()